Cooperstown Crier - Your Source for Hometown News - Cooperstown, Baseball Hall of Fame

Book Notes

August 19, 2011

Book Notes: Riding the funeral train

Throughout history there have always been “hidden” stories that get overlooked in textbooks that have greater significance that one realizes at the time.

Fortunately we don’t lack for historians looking for a “good” story so they usually get published somewhere along the line. I was recently advised of one such chronicle that brings to light a compelling moment in our nation’s history. I was an American history major in college and focused much of my studies on Franklin Delano Roosevelt (FDR).

Like most people I knew he guided the country through the New Deal and World War II. He was elected four times and died shortly after his fourth term began. His death was a shock to the nation, and many people could not recall a time when he was not president. I knew a lot about his policies and personal life, but even I didn’t know the numerous dilemmas that were created by his death on April 12, 1945.

Robert Klara, a New Yorkbased editor and writer, has published a book that examines this often overlooked nugget in American history called “FDR’s Funeral Train: a Betrayed Widow, a Soviet Spy, and a Presidency in the Balance.”

Among other details, we learn how close Roosevelt was to death during his last year in office, how much he left his vice-president, Harry Truman, in the dark, and how the relationship between Eleanor and Franklin had disintegrated to the point where they were married in name only. In Roosevelt’s 12 years as president the most difficult question is whether he should have run for re-election in 1944. We were in the middle of the war, and his inner circle did not feel the country was ready for a change in leadership.

From a purely medical standpoint it was an unconscionable decision. Klara presents a man who was clearly in his last throes. Roosevelt’s personal physician comes across as a real villain for certifying FDR’s “healthy” state. Many of FDR’s associates and friends, despite doubts, assumed that he must be OK if his physician certified it.

Even if one takes the position that it’s acceptable to run for re-election during wartime when you’re on death’s doorstep it is unforgiveable to leave your vice-president in the dark about wartime operations.

Truman had no idea the atom bomb was being developed. He was treated like most VPs who are left to attend funerals for foreign VIPs and work on their golf game.

Truman essentially had NO working relationship with FDR. His accent to the vice presidency was purely a political move to boost Roosevelt’s re-election chances. He spent the entire time on the funeral train from Washington, D.C. to Hyde Park and back working on a speech he would deliver to Congress upon his return.

Whether you liked him or not, the remarkable thing about Truman is that he stepped up to the plate. His wartime speech to Congress was a major success. He had the sign “The buck stops here” on his desk, and made the gutsy decisions to drop the bomb, integrate the armed forces, and to fire a war hero (Douglas MacArthur) for insubordination.

And all this from a man from humble origins who had no clue what was going on in FDR’s war plans. If Truman had not been picked as FDR’s running mate in 1944 he would have been a mere footnote in history.

I will take a little of the suspense away by saying that the “Soviet Spy” teaser in the title is the least suspenseful part of the story.

There was a Russian spy on the train but that’s about it. He didn’t glean any information or commit any sabotage.

The story of how this American citizen became a traitor and secured a government job is an intriguing one but his presence on the train was nothing more than that.

One unusual aspect of the funeral train is that all the nation’s VIPs were in one place at the same time. That would never happen today. The fear of sabotage or terrorist attack would prevent such an occurrence.

When Truman was president, secret service protection was minimal enough that he could take a daily walk in the neighborhood around the White House. These days traffic is even blocked from driving in front of it.

It would be interesting to see how the 24/7 press, cable news, and online blogs  would handle Roosevelt’spersonal life today.

Most Americans didn’t even know he was confined to a wheel chair, and few knew he and Eleanor were husband and wife in name only. Perhaps the greatest mystery of all is how Eleanor could handle not only finding out that the last person with her husband was his former mistress (one he had  promised 27 years earliernever to see again) but that her daughter Anna arranged the rendezvous.

Klara’s book is not perfect. He spends too much time talking about the technical aspects of the train’s operation but it’s a minor distraction.

The important thing is that you get a feel for the nation’s loss and how our leaders and ordinary citizens reacted in a time of crisis. It’s a fascinating look at one of the most dramatic moments in our nation’s history.

1
Text Only
Book Notes
  • Early 'blahs' sometimes hide a gem There are often films that sound rather "blah" when you first notice them and have no interest in seeing. It's usually due to the preview either being really stupid or the producers wanting to avoid giving away too much of the plot. If it's the latter category you must be careful. Sometimes there's a gem of a movie hidden behind the facade.

    July 24, 2014

  • 'Moneyball' author tackles Wall Street with 'Flash Boys' Have you ever read a book that feels like it's in a foreign language? It covers a subject you know is important and figure at some point it will all make sense. What do you do when that doesn't happen? Obviously, the easiest solution is to toss the book aside. But what if the underlying message is something you "get" and don't want to give up on? I faced that dilemma recently.

    July 17, 2014

  • MacNeil reading highlights novels Several weeks ago I had the good fortune to attend a talk by Robert MacNeil at the Guilderland Public Library. MacNeil is best known as the former co-host of the MacNeil/Lehrer NewsHour on PBS. He retired in 1995 but has continued to write both fiction and non-fiction. His talk at Guilderland focused on two of his novels, "Burden of Desire" written in 1992, and its sequel, "Portrait of Julia," which was published last year.

    July 10, 2014

  • 'The Monuments Men' shows important history World War II continues to hold a special place in the hearts of readers and movie goers. The reasons are many but much of it can be traced to the endless number of storylines from that conflict. There is literally a treasure trove of material that keeps emerging. The latest example is the movie, “The Monuments Men.â€�

    July 3, 2014

  • Authors not afraid to think like freaks Conventional wisdom is something we automatically take for granted. It can be something as simple as assuming there is no cure for the common cold or political polls being a good indicator of who will win an election. Common assumptions of course can be wrong but we usually just accept them as fact. However, in many cases it would be much better to think "outside the box" and consider an alternative way of looking at the world.

    June 26, 2014

  • Book goes further into Armstrong's lies There hasn't been a shortage of elite athletes that have fallen from grace in recent years. Most of them have been baseball players who have been caught using performance enhancing drugs (PEDs) and then lying about it. Golfer Tiger Woods fell from his pedestal because of extra-marital affairs. He has yet to regain his previous aura and perhaps never will. But the loudest crash of all came from cyclist Lance Armstrong who was not only a liar and a cheat but ruined other people's lives in the process.

    June 19, 2014

  • Documentary proves Butch, Sundance still enchant "Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid" is one of the most popular films of all-time. The 1969 Western is based on the real life exploits of two infamous outlaws whose specialty was robbing trains. They became folk heroes because they supposedly never shot anyone.

    June 12, 2014

  • Pohl's call-up reminds me of Feinstein book We recently learned that Cooperstown native and professional baseball player Phillip Pohl was promoted to the AAA farm team of the Oakland Athletics where he played for nearly a month. For those that don't know, AAA is the highest minor league before reaching the major leagues.

    June 5, 2014

  • Movie gives clues into real Disney Everyone has heard of Walt Disney. How can you not when Disneyland and Disney World are the most popular family vacation spots around. Add in his historic cartoons and animated features and you have a Hollywood legend. But how many people know what the man himself was like?

    May 29, 2014

  • Wooden bio by Davis feels definitive Any long-time observer of college basketball knows that one school and one coach stand out above all others. In the 1960s and 1970s the John Wooden-led UCLA Bruins won ten championships in twelve seasons. Their level of achievement is so remarkable that it will probably never be equaled. Forty years after his last championship the ghost of John Wooden still reverberates at the university.

    May 22, 2014