Cooperstown Crier - Your Source for Hometown News - Cooperstown, Baseball Hall of Fame

Book Notes

August 19, 2011

Book Notes: Riding the funeral train

Throughout history there have always been “hidden” stories that get overlooked in textbooks that have greater significance that one realizes at the time.

Fortunately we don’t lack for historians looking for a “good” story so they usually get published somewhere along the line. I was recently advised of one such chronicle that brings to light a compelling moment in our nation’s history. I was an American history major in college and focused much of my studies on Franklin Delano Roosevelt (FDR).

Like most people I knew he guided the country through the New Deal and World War II. He was elected four times and died shortly after his fourth term began. His death was a shock to the nation, and many people could not recall a time when he was not president. I knew a lot about his policies and personal life, but even I didn’t know the numerous dilemmas that were created by his death on April 12, 1945.

Robert Klara, a New Yorkbased editor and writer, has published a book that examines this often overlooked nugget in American history called “FDR’s Funeral Train: a Betrayed Widow, a Soviet Spy, and a Presidency in the Balance.”

Among other details, we learn how close Roosevelt was to death during his last year in office, how much he left his vice-president, Harry Truman, in the dark, and how the relationship between Eleanor and Franklin had disintegrated to the point where they were married in name only. In Roosevelt’s 12 years as president the most difficult question is whether he should have run for re-election in 1944. We were in the middle of the war, and his inner circle did not feel the country was ready for a change in leadership.

From a purely medical standpoint it was an unconscionable decision. Klara presents a man who was clearly in his last throes. Roosevelt’s personal physician comes across as a real villain for certifying FDR’s “healthy” state. Many of FDR’s associates and friends, despite doubts, assumed that he must be OK if his physician certified it.

Even if one takes the position that it’s acceptable to run for re-election during wartime when you’re on death’s doorstep it is unforgiveable to leave your vice-president in the dark about wartime operations.

Truman had no idea the atom bomb was being developed. He was treated like most VPs who are left to attend funerals for foreign VIPs and work on their golf game.

Truman essentially had NO working relationship with FDR. His accent to the vice presidency was purely a political move to boost Roosevelt’s re-election chances. He spent the entire time on the funeral train from Washington, D.C. to Hyde Park and back working on a speech he would deliver to Congress upon his return.

Whether you liked him or not, the remarkable thing about Truman is that he stepped up to the plate. His wartime speech to Congress was a major success. He had the sign “The buck stops here” on his desk, and made the gutsy decisions to drop the bomb, integrate the armed forces, and to fire a war hero (Douglas MacArthur) for insubordination.

And all this from a man from humble origins who had no clue what was going on in FDR’s war plans. If Truman had not been picked as FDR’s running mate in 1944 he would have been a mere footnote in history.

I will take a little of the suspense away by saying that the “Soviet Spy” teaser in the title is the least suspenseful part of the story.

There was a Russian spy on the train but that’s about it. He didn’t glean any information or commit any sabotage.

The story of how this American citizen became a traitor and secured a government job is an intriguing one but his presence on the train was nothing more than that.

One unusual aspect of the funeral train is that all the nation’s VIPs were in one place at the same time. That would never happen today. The fear of sabotage or terrorist attack would prevent such an occurrence.

When Truman was president, secret service protection was minimal enough that he could take a daily walk in the neighborhood around the White House. These days traffic is even blocked from driving in front of it.

It would be interesting to see how the 24/7 press, cable news, and online blogs  would handle Roosevelt’spersonal life today.

Most Americans didn’t even know he was confined to a wheel chair, and few knew he and Eleanor were husband and wife in name only. Perhaps the greatest mystery of all is how Eleanor could handle not only finding out that the last person with her husband was his former mistress (one he had  promised 27 years earliernever to see again) but that her daughter Anna arranged the rendezvous.

Klara’s book is not perfect. He spends too much time talking about the technical aspects of the train’s operation but it’s a minor distraction.

The important thing is that you get a feel for the nation’s loss and how our leaders and ordinary citizens reacted in a time of crisis. It’s a fascinating look at one of the most dramatic moments in our nation’s history.

Text Only
Book Notes
  • Libraries provide vital services Some people think that libraries are becoming obsolete due to the Internet and the growing popularity of e-books. Nothing could be further from the truth. Libraries are a repository for more than just the written word and reference materials. They provide a basic need for every community and will for the foreseeable future.

    April 17, 2014

  • WWII collection grows with 'Those Angry Days' The main lesson history teaches us is to learn from our mistakes and not repeat them. There’s also an old saying that insanity is doing the same thing over and over and expecting a different result. Perhaps the two notions have something in common because we continually prove that history does indeed repeat itself.

    April 10, 2014

  • 'Blue Jasmine' shows talent of troubled Allen It's a shame that Woody Allen is caught up in controversy in his personal life because it deflects from his talent as a filmmaker. You can see the brilliance in his most recent release, "Blue Jasmine" now available for rental at the Cooperstown Library.

    April 3, 2014

  • 'Nebraska' helps give Dern his due Bruce Dern has been a character actor for over half a century yet hadn't really gotten the acclaim he deserves.

    March 27, 2014

  • Book captures both sides of 'Splended Splinter' Ted Williams is an American icon. As the mainstay of the Boston Red Sox from 1939-1960 he was one of baseball’s all-time greats, a first ballot Hall-of-Famer, and perhaps the greatest hitter the sport has ever known. He was admired for his devotion to the game, his service to his country, and his support for children with cancer. But there was an ugly side to him too. Williams’ life was a set of contradictions where his talent and humanity were offset by fits of rage and cold-heartedness.

    March 20, 2014

  • Wouk has amazing body of epic work One of the problems with eulogies is that they only seem to occur posthumously. I often wonder why people who have produced something noteworthy aren't honored until after they die and don't get to hear the acclaim they deserve. In that vein I want to recognize an aging classic novelist while he is still with us.

    March 13, 2014

  • 'Miracle' shows when Olympics were pure The Winter Olympics ended recently and somehow they seemed to have lost their luster. It wasn’t so much that they were in Sochi where most of the events were on tape delay. It was more due to the new events (many we have never heard of) that have diluted the games. The Winter Olympics have gone from an intimate edition of their summer counterpart to one where it appears medal counts and commercialism is all that matters.

    March 6, 2014

  • Sometimes bad films, books called 'Classic' About 40 years ago a movie was made that set the standard for overhyped and underwhelming films. It was "The Great Gatsby" starring Robert Redford and Mia Farrow. Redford was the hottest thing in Hollywood at the time and Time Magazine ran a cover story on the film. When it was finally released it completely bombed.

    February 27, 2014

  • British films that will warm your heart With all the snow and sub-zero temperatures this winter there are enough nights where the easiest thing to do is hunker down and enjoy a good movie. I thought I’d offer a few suggestions with a British twist. These are films with Americans that are filmed in England. The one thing they all have in common is that they’ll warm your heart in the end.

    February 20, 2014

  • Giants-Dodgers rivalry entertains One of the fiercest rivalries in all of sports is the Giants and Dodgers. These two proud franchises have been going at it for well over 100 years. First it was New York vs. Brooklyn. Now it's San Francisco vs. Los Angeles. There's no love lost between them. Victories over each other are sweeter than those over any other team. Even when they're not going head-to-head it feels good when their arch-rival loses. If you're a Giants' fan, hating the Dodgers is a way of life (and vice versa).

    February 13, 2014