Cooperstown Crier - Your Source for Hometown News - Cooperstown, Baseball Hall of Fame


February 7, 2013


‘Redskin’ is a racial slur

I am writing to support the Cooperstown Central School Board’s decision to reopen the question of changing the sports teams’ nickname from the “Redskins.” 

I personally believe that this nickname is a detriment to the school and its athletes for a variety of reasons. As the issue of history and heritage are used to support both sides of this argument, I think that it is time we review our community’s historical connection between Cooperstown and the native peoples of this region. We share a rich heritage, and there is much to be proud of in this regard. For hundreds of years, prior to the 18th century, Otsego Lake was a center of Native American life in the Northeast, with the Haudensaunee and Algonquin people using the Susquehanna River and lake as major routes of transportation that extended over many thousands of square miles.

We also know that the lake was an important hunting and fishing site for the native settlements in the Mohawk Valley. The evidence of these peoples’ lives is all around us; it is turned up every spring when local farmers plow their fields and discover arrowheads and pot shards, and it is in the very place names that define our community.  Otsego, Susquehanna, Oneonta, and Council Rock are among the many place names that come down to us from our native forebears.

To the extent that we believe in the power of history and that we understand Cooperstown to be a place blessed in its heritage, we must also understand that there is a dark element to this history that makes the school’s use of the term “Redskins” as the team nickname particularly egregious. In the summer of 1779 the Clinton-Sullivan Campaign that had the primary objective of destroying the homes, villages and crops of the Iroquois people in order to drive them from their ancestral homes, was launched from the present site of Cooperstown. This campaign was one of the largest military operations waged in North America during the American Revolution and involved thousands of soldiers and hundreds of bateaux (wooden military boats) sailing down the Susquehanna and destroying every village, crop and orchard that they came across.

Text Only
  • Please Click Here I have always gone to the library. When I was young, my mother took my siblings and me to our local library at least once a week to select books. I felt I had the world at my fingertips, so many books to explore!

    April 3, 2014

  • Please Click Here Never have I written back-to-back letters to the editor, but so many Cooperstown people have called our home or talked with me on the street to comment on my previous letter about the Furthur concert.

    July 25, 2013

  • Our Readers' Opinions Once again nature is wreaking havoc with our properties surrounding the lake! The amount of rain we have received in the last month is approximately 13 inches -- three times the normal amount!

    July 11, 2013

  • Honest Brook Music Festival to celebrate 25th anniversary The Honest Brook Music Festival has announced its 25th anniversary summer season classical concerts.

    July 4, 2013

  • Our Readers' Opinions After living in the western southern tier for 10 years, my wife and I decided to visit the Hall of Fame today, June 20, before moving out of the area in a few weeks. We enjoyed the museum, but parking in Cooperstown proved to be a formidable gauntlet.

    June 27, 2013

  • Our Readers' Opinions To Those members of the local government who care about the economic future of Cooperstown and the maintenance of its character: Has Town Hall gone mad here?

    June 13, 2013

  • Our Readers' Opinions I applaud the Baseball HOF's move of the Classic to Memorial Day Saturday. I just wished it had not been rained out.

    June 6, 2013

  • Our Readers' Opinions Regarding the April 4 letter from Margaret McGown et al, I understand why the letter's authors are disappointed with the decision of Otsego Land Trust to discontinue renting private dock space. All concerned should understand that we did not take any actions without careful consideration and ultimate approval by our Board of Directors.

    April 11, 2013

  • Please Click Here We read, with great interest, the article regarding Brookwood Point and the statement by Mr. Harry Levine that the Otego Land Trust is in need of donors to keep up the property and raise enough money to match the Historic Byways grant.

    April 4, 2013

  • In Our Readers' Opinions The organizers of the seventh annual Empty Bowls fundraiser would like to thank everyone who volunteered, donated and attended our event on March 2.

    March 28, 2013